Standards of judicial review of administrative bodies : The consideration of citizen participation
By: TAUCAR, Christopher Edward
.
Material type: 
ArticlePublisher: Toronto : Ipac, mar./mars 2010Subject(s): Participação Social | Legitimidade | Tomada de Decisão | Burocracia | CanadáCanadian Public Administration 53, 1, p. 67-86Abstract: In Canada there is little legitimate or legal room or consistency with the judicial role in judicial review of or appeal from administrative actions or decisions for courts to take into account the degree or quality of citizen participation to support greater deference for administrative decision or action. At most, this consideration may be considered a sub-factor, marginal and never determinative. In particular, citizen participation can be a sub-factor when the public perception is either explicitly central to the legislation in issue, or is assumed or inferred as such by the court. Nevertheless, assuming such citizen participation in bureaucracy is positive, there can be some significant indirect coincidental promotion of it in reality as a result of and through judicial deference to administrative decisions, which occurs concomitantly in standard-of-review analysis
In Canada there is little legitimate or legal room or consistency with the judicial role in judicial review of or appeal from administrative actions or decisions for courts to take into account the degree or quality of citizen participation to support greater deference for administrative decision or action. At most, this consideration may be considered a sub-factor, marginal and never determinative. In particular, citizen participation can be a sub-factor when the public perception is either explicitly central to the legislation in issue, or is assumed or inferred as such by the court. Nevertheless, assuming such citizen participation in bureaucracy is positive, there can be some significant indirect coincidental promotion of it in reality as a result of and through judicial deference to administrative decisions, which occurs concomitantly in standard-of-review analysis
Click on an image to view it in the image viewer
There are no comments for this item.