000 02223naa a2200181uu 4500
001 7010514445321
003 OSt
005 20190211162108.0
008 070105s2007 xx ||||gr |0|| 0 eng d
100 1 _aSAXONHOUSE, Arlene W
_929698
245 1 0 _aDemocracy, equality, and eide :
_ba radical view from Book 8 of Plato's Republic
260 _aNew York, NY :
_bCambridge University Press,
_cJune 1998
520 3 _aAn elitist Plato, opposed to democracy and hostile to the masses, fills the literature. In the midst of an extensive philological and grammatical commentary on Plato's Republic, James Adam (1902, 2.24, ad loc. 494a) includes the following brief but telling observation: "The theory of Ideas is not a democratic philosophy." He writes this in response to an interchange between Socrates and Adeimantus concerning the access of the many to the idea or form of the Good, during which Socrates claims: "It is impossible for the multitude to be philosophic." Only a few will have access to the forms (eide).(1) A profound inequality of rule and authority seems to follow from that unequal access. I could begin with Adam's assertion that the theory of ideas is not a democratic philosophy, but the basis for my argument derives from a very different perspective, an epistemological one that has nothing to do with the capabilities, or lack thereof, of the many to attain a vision of the Good. Rather, I focus on the theory of the forms as a mechanism for categorization, opposing epistemologically, politically, and psychologically the openness of democracy. While Adam and numerous others see elitism in the Platonic theory of the forms because the many cannot ascend to a philosophic vision,(2) I attend to the opposition between democracy and that theory to illustrate how Socrates' discussion in Book 8 of the Republic points to democracy's dependence on a "formlessness" that challenges claims of equality and of identity within democratic regimes.
773 0 8 _tAmerican Political Science Review
_g92, 2, p. 273-284
_dNew York, NY : Cambridge University Press, June 1998
_xISSN 0003-0554
_w
942 _cS
998 _a20070105
_b1444^b
_cNatália
998 _a20070105
_b1716^b
_cNatália
999 _aConvertido do Formato PHL
_bPHL2MARC21 1.1
_c21244
_d21244
041 _aeng