<style type="text/css"> .wpb_animate_when_almost_visible { opacity: 1; }</style> Enap catalog › Details for: No place to hide :
Normal view MARC view ISBD view

No place to hide : the unfeasibility of using an independent expert commission as a blameavoidance mechanism in westminster polities - the case of the Ontario Health Services Restructuring Commission

By: COHN, Daniel.
Material type: materialTypeLabelArticlePublisher: 2001Canadian Public Administration 44, 1, p. 26-46Abstract: The argument presented in this article is that the appointment of an ad hoc expert commission to carry out governance is unlikely to depoliticize difficult restructuring issues or to deflect blame from governments dealing with such problems in Westminster-style polities. Unlike in America-style presidential systems and parliamentray systems with proportional representation experiencing frequent minority governments, such commissions can never be truly independente as there are no serious checks on the government`s ability to remake the agency, its mandate, its composition, nor even any barriers to the government`s premature termination of and ad hoc expert comission`s authority. When governments in a Westminister-style polity seek to establish the appearance that such a commission is an independent agency of governance they must work at cross-purposes to the basic rules for insuring accountability by giving such a body a very vague mandate. This will almost certainty lead to disputes between political actors and the commission over its powers and refocus blame on the government. The ministers of a government employing this strategy must also be extraordinarily cargul so as not to engage in any activities that would undermine the ad hoc expert commission`s already fragile claim to autonomy, otherwise the blame focused on the government will magnify even futher. The difficulties involved in employing an ad hoc expert commission as a means to depoliticize decisions and as a blasme-avoidance strategy for governments in westminster-stuyle polities are illustrated in the Ontario government`s experience with the Health Services Restructuring Commission (HSRC)
Tags from this library: No tags from this library for this title. Log in to add tags.
    average rating: 0.0 (0 votes)
Item type Current location Collection Call number Status Date due Barcode
Periódico Biblioteca Graciliano Ramos
Periódico Not for loan

The argument presented in this article is that the appointment of an ad hoc expert commission to carry out governance is unlikely to depoliticize difficult restructuring issues or to deflect blame from governments dealing with such problems in Westminster-style polities. Unlike in America-style presidential systems and parliamentray systems with proportional representation experiencing frequent minority governments, such commissions can never be truly independente as there are no serious checks on the government`s ability to remake the agency, its mandate, its composition, nor even any barriers to the government`s premature termination of and ad hoc expert comission`s authority. When governments in a Westminister-style polity seek to establish the appearance that such a commission is an independent agency of governance they must work at cross-purposes to the basic rules for insuring accountability by giving such a body a very vague mandate. This will almost certainty lead to disputes between political actors and the commission over its powers and refocus blame on the government. The ministers of a government employing this strategy must also be extraordinarily cargul so as not to engage in any activities that would undermine the ad hoc expert commission`s already fragile claim to autonomy, otherwise the blame focused on the government will magnify even futher. The difficulties involved in employing an ad hoc expert commission as a means to depoliticize decisions and as a blasme-avoidance strategy for governments in westminster-stuyle polities are illustrated in the Ontario government`s experience with the Health Services Restructuring Commission (HSRC)

There are no comments for this item.

Log in to your account to post a comment.

Click on an image to view it in the image viewer

Escola Nacional de Administração Pública

Escola Nacional de Administração Pública

Endereço:

  • Biblioteca Graciliano Ramos
  • Funcionamento: segunda a sexta-feira, das 9h às 19h
  • +55 61 2020-3139 / biblioteca@enap.gov.br
  • SPO Área Especial 2-A
  • CEP 70610-900 - Brasília/DF
<
Acesso à Informação TRANSPARÊNCIA

Powered by Koha